AaronT said:
The Maverick solves a lot of DD problems in one slick package. The Z is a sports car so it doesn't solve any problems and isn't terribly cheap, but as a sports car it has to compete with Miatas and Toyobarus which are both lighter, old Boxsters with better feel, or pony cars that are a lot faster. It doesn't tick the right boxes for a lot of people.
That's kind of my frustration with threads like this one. Sports cars solve the most pressing problem - FUN. Sports cars are the thing that most embodies our shared interest on this forum, but there's often a ton of negativity about legitimately good ones. Whether it's; 1. A fun street car. 2. A street car used for autoX/lapping. 3. A dedicated race car. 4. A future crap can racer - cars like this need to exist and be enjoyed. A Maverick can certainly haul more boxes of Depends from Costco, but is that really what this forum is all about? I'm unfortunately no longer able to do use case #2 or #4, but I will be damned if I'm going to have more interest in an appliance than a legitimately good sports car. The 370Z is a solid choice, just like the other options you mentioned. If I was doing #2, a 370Z would be in my garage right now.
Another caveat to my, be willing to pay, is be willing to travel or have a car shipped.
'88 325 - had shipped from Florida.
'91 318 - Flew to NJ and drove back to OK
'09 V8 4Runner - Flew to Austin and drove back
'06 Miata - drove to Paris, TX and drove back
'13 135i - drove the BRZ to Indianapolis, traded-ed it in and drove back. We did that in 1.5 days.
'06 Miata - worked out a deal to have it delivered from Kentucky.
'87 RX-7 Turbo II - 2 hours. Drove first, bought later. Great price.
'06 RX-8 - 2 hours. Put down a deposit, subject to test drive later, drove back later. 3 years old, 14k miles, <1/3 cost of new!
'94 Miata - Bought 7 hours away, sight unseen, shipped. Good price/condition for price/bought to fit rulebook.
'17 Camaro SS - 7 hours drive, sight unseen, travelled to get it by train, bunch of extra legwork/hassle. Great deal at the time, didn't work out well, but no way of knowing what the future would hold.
'16 FiST - Fly and drive, 11 hours away. Good deal, great condition/add ons, low miles. Got a fun vacation out of it too.