revhard
revhard New Reader
10/31/13 7:59 a.m.

So for the last two or three weeks I've been on the hunt for a car for my mom. She has a 2000 windstar with 144k that needs a valve job. Its ready to give up the ghost any day now. She seems to prefer the small cuv's (RAV 4, CR-V, and Forester).

She needs the car to be 2007 or newer, ideally 2010 for financing reasons. She has a budget of up to $17k but ideally hover around $15k or less.

So i went to the local subaru dealership looking at some used foresters and as i pulled into the parking lot i see a 2007 forester XT. Its another customer's car that hes trying to trade in. I strike up a chat with the guy and tell him if he doesn't trade it in to give me a call. Later that night he calls me and gives me all the details.

2007 forester xt sport 5 speed manual 110,000 miles new turbo, transmission, clutch done in the last 30k miles timing belt and radiator done 5k miles ago. turbo back exhaust. tuned

This is a car id love to jump on for myself but then im looking for my mom. Is this the kind of car i want to put her in? She's willing to daily a manual as that's how she grew up driving but shes also in her early 60's.

The guy is looking for loan payout which is 13k. Dealer trade in seems to hover around $7k-9k and he told me the dealer was hesitant to take it in on trade because of the miles.

What should i look out for on this year and model? Should i be worried about the miles or relax since most of the major services have been done already? and whats a fair price to pay?

oh and if anyone feels like chiming in about rav-4's or cr-v's, that would be appreciated too.

JohnRW1621
JohnRW1621 UltimaDork
10/31/13 8:07 a.m.

Rav4's and CRV's are the easiest cars to recommend to a typical non-sporty driver. They do just about everything that normal people want and do it very well. Hard to go wrong with either, they just command a price premium due to this desirability.

Maybe also consider an Accord Crosstour if it fits in the budget.

Klayfish
Klayfish SuperDork
10/31/13 8:10 a.m.

It's a question you'd have to ask your mother. I would bet most women in their early 60's would have little to no interest driving around in a stick shift turbo with 110k on the clock. But YMMV. If she wants a small SUV to rely on for daily transportation, she may be more satisfied with an auto equipped CR-V, RAV4, Forester, Outlander, Tuscon, Sorrento, Murano, etc...

ebonyandivory
ebonyandivory Dork
10/31/13 8:19 a.m.

What is your daily driver? You could buy the Forester and give her your daily!

revhard
revhard New Reader
10/31/13 8:23 a.m.

I daily an audi a4 that's also stick.Shes driven it a few times to work and the only complaint she has was that it was too low to the ground.

Sounds like cr-v's and rav-4's would be the safer bet.

ebonyandivory
ebonyandivory Dork
10/31/13 8:49 a.m.

I for one would like to high-five your mom for being willing to drive a manual. I'll agree with your last point as well.

ddavidv
ddavidv PowerDork
10/31/13 5:04 p.m.

Forester XT is "premium fuel required". That crossed it off our list.

We went from a Forester to a Jeep Patriot (available with the stick). Way cheaper than the overly worshipped Subarus and not near as bad as you probably think they are. Give them a look.

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
yLCwIkXL9uvQQSXDLpennH6GSsr7vfXPQ6sDRC2PQ3slkElFz7OK5mSmdVRPOKQs