Adrian_Thompson wrote:
Tom_Spangler wrote:
I have more thoughts, but I need help from you guys to convince him that it would be worth it to travel a bit to find the right (ie, rust-free) car, since he wants to keep it for 10+ years.
Give me your thoughts. I'm not agaisnt traveling for a car, but by they time you've done a 500 mile round trip that's another $200 you could add to the local budget. You made the same point yourself in the Cheap Milwaukee BMW engine thread today.
I did, but I was talking about an engine that I don't really need for a car I already have. You are talking about a car that you will be emotionally invested in (I know you) for a decade-plus. If getting the right one means you subtract a bit from your budget to make a road trip for a cleaner example, I think it's worth it.
I'm obviously biased and have been trying to push Ade towards an E30 all summer, including going to look at a couple with him. I just think it's a damn-near unbeatable combination of cheapness, strong aftermarket and internet support, a pretty decent suspension setup that doesn't need a welder to make it very good, and an engine bay that will accept all kinds of crazy powerplants to replace the already-decent stock one.
As for the others:
Miata: I've had one, autocrossed several others, and I like them, but it wasn't for me. Too small, too underpowered, and the convertible thing is a big negative for rallycross and track days. Roll bars aren't cheap and they tend to limit seat travel.
Fiat Spider: Well, they are pretty, but other than that it seems to me you'd be better off with a Miata, but it still has all the Miata's negatives.
XR4Ti: If you can find a decent one, I say go for it. Good power in stock form, a valve away from silly power, decent chassis, funky styling that you won't see yourself coming and going, it's a Ford.
RX-7s: I've had one of these (FB), too, and that experience left me feeling that these are great cars as soon as you rip that rotary out and put in a real engine. Sorry....
924/944: I'd go 944 all day for the looks, but good luck finding a cheap, decent one. Aftermarket is there, but the parts still tend to be expensive. Then there's the double whammy of clutch and timing belt. I love these, but not on a tight budget.
Saab: Yes, it's a bit out of left field, but you have to love 80s turbo motors and all their potential. Undeniable rally heritage, rarity, and retro-cool factor. Downsides are the FWD and I have no idea how the aftermarket is for these, but it can't be as good as the Miata or E30. Plus, they are hard to find.
I know nothing about those old Volvos, so moving on.
Sciriocco: Another classic of 80s styling, and (as I understand it) Mk. 1 Golf/Rabbit underpinnings mean lots of parts availability and interchange. They don't seem to be too expensive, either. Limited power potential, though, and FWD, of course.
Anyhow, the answer is E30.