I looked around, and decided to relist on CL with more photos and "no trades", made it $4900 OBO in case $5k was scaring them off (like charging $4.99 vs $5). I also went with Autotrader and the Enhanced option. $50 includes 9 photos and runs two months. If it doesn't sell by middle of October there's a good chance it'll wait till spring.
Ebay wanted $125 and extra $ to make it a reserve auction. My other option was BaT and not out of the picture just yet. See what Autotrader does.