frenchyd
frenchyd UltimaDork
2/7/22 12:10 p.m.

You gave me the light bulb moment that solved the issue of OBD2. 
     I was wrong. All the rest of you who told me I didn't need it were right.

 

    Here's were my mistake was.  Jaguar V12 has a stand alone ignition system. Using a Chevy module to trigger the ignition. 
 Yank the ECM off and replace the EFI with  carbs and it still runs.  
     I kept wondering how  the system knew it was a 12 cylinder and not a V8. I had read many times it was batch fired.   But how does the system know it's a 12 cylinder. 
   Finally it dawned on me. It doesn't,   it just squirts a bunch of fuel and the valves open when it's their turn.  The amount it squirts is based on input from the various sensors. 
     The light bulb moment was PaulVR6  said if there is something wrong it won't run.   In my head my hypothetical was say the fuel pressure sensor went out. All I knew was the engine stopped running.

Paul VR6  said the data logger would have that information.  Hook up the lap top see what information was off and go from there.  Bingo !  
 

Several had told me that earlier. But since I didn't ask the question,  nobody explained it. 
 I kept going back to the idea of input from the OBD2  but you were right,  it's displayed in the laptop.    Hooking up the laptop takes about the same time/ effort as plugging in a reader. 

AnthonyGS (Forum Supporter)
AnthonyGS (Forum Supporter) SuperDork
2/7/22 12:41 p.m.

Honestly, I figured you had a basic understanding of EFI when you started that thread.  Most all OEMs started with a Bosch designed system.  When I first started playing with EFI cars, I read the Bosch EFI book.  Diagnosing, repairing and tuning will be much easier if you understand this book.  
 

https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/bosch-fuel-injection-and-engine-management-bosch_charles-o-probst/400349/item/4525087/?gclid=CjwKCAiAo4OQBhBBEiwA5KWu_yL-6Xz7A2JT_rPXEgNzjWRHFl7StWZLc1b8VDB2g3uBOqgxuqGDbBoCBaAQAvD_BwE#idiq=4525087&edition=3629221

 

This is a way newer version than what I read, but I'm sure it still covers the basics and painful details.  
 

 

frenchyd
frenchyd UltimaDork
2/7/22 12:50 p.m.
AnthonyGS (Forum Supporter) said:

Honestly, I figured you had a basic understanding of EFI when you started that thread.  Most all OEMs started with a Bosch designed system.  When I first started playing with EFI cars, I read the Bosch EFI book.  Diagnosing, repairing and tuning will be much easier if you understand this book.  
 

https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/bosch-fuel-injection-and-engine-management-bosch_charles-o-probst/400349/item/4525087/?gclid=CjwKCAiAo4OQBhBBEiwA5KWu_yL-6Xz7A2JT_rPXEgNzjWRHFl7StWZLc1b8VDB2g3uBOqgxuqGDbBoCBaAQAvD_BwE#idiq=4525087&edition=3629221

 

This is a way newer version than what I read, but I'm sure it still covers the basics and painful details.  
 

 

Yes I read and reread every book and magazine article I could get my hands on. I've got a whole crate of just EFI books.  That are  actually dog eared. 
   I guess I just learn different. In Navy Flight school everybody but me got done flying they went out. Me I stayed on base rereading and rereading the books assigned. The verbal test the next day I always did well because I had actually memorized word for word  everything in the book.  
 I didn't know what it meant but I sure did well.  
 

MadScientistMatt
MadScientistMatt UltimaDork
2/7/22 2:26 p.m.

OBD2 has a lot of useful diagnostic capabilities - the catch is that it takes a team of factory calibration engineers to program in what conditions trigger these. Well and good if you're using it to tune the engine they set the OBD2 up to diagnose. A massive headache if you've tried to transplant the OBD2 system onto a completely different engine. You'll have an easier time looking at the raw sensor readings to see what is and isn't working.

Paul_VR6 (Forum Supporter)
Paul_VR6 (Forum Supporter) SuperDork
2/7/22 7:39 p.m.

Np frenchy. Obd2 even gets wigged out by modifications. Back in the dark ages we could tell we were on a run bc the ecu would be showing misfires on rapid accel bc the rate of change math was both ways and we could trigger it by revving too fast. A few passes in we would have to reset the ecu cool

frenchyd
frenchyd UltimaDork
2/7/22 8:00 p.m.

Hey thanks to everyone who tried to help me understand EFI. I'm sorry I failed  to understand . 
    Please let's not make it a Frenchy problem

I know there are plenty of people willing to help others  here. Let's try to keep this site open?  
Post your questions, problems, thoughts, solutions, and guidance. 
     If you have a  good experience  with a company ( or bad) product or equipment  talk about it. 
Ask the site moderators if it can be done. 
  The wonderful thing about GRM is the community they have generated.  I feel positive they will respond if sufficient interest is shown. 

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
fQLV49H0HzXXrmhKF9YtKYW41C3cAKeEz6Wbtd1B24jCy4BNOKRW7zG3qGpBdEnE