Tony Sestito said:. Chiefs will win, and the inevitable "Mahomes is the real GOAT" rhetoric will start. Blah....
No one with eyes is saying this yet, and I'm saying that as a dyed-in-the-wool Chiefs and Mahomes fan. What is clear that if anyone playing right now has a chance at matching Brady's body of work...it's Mahomes. He's speedrunning the HOF career.
Just for the hell of it, let's look at where Brady was compared to Mahomes after six seasons starting. Mahomes 2018-now, Brady 2001-2006.
Brady had 3 superbowl appearances, 3 wins. 2 Superbowl MVPs. 3 Pro Bowl nods, one second team All-Pro. No MVP yet (first one was 2007). By the end of that stretch, he wasn't even the guy. Manning was still the QB every defensive coordinator didn't want to face. Granted, this was before Moss/Gronk/Edelman.
Mahomes has 4 superbowl appearances, 2 wins (one unplayed yet). Six pro bowls, 2 first team All-Pro, one second team. Two MVP's, one of which was one of the best seasons a quarterback ever had. Mahomes has had a better start to his career up to this point.
Biggest difference between the two is that Mahomes started his career with HOF receivers, and Brady didn' t get his until Moss and Welker got there in 2007. (And yes, I realize Welker is Hall of Very Good, not Hall of Fame.)
I'm in the boat that Brady is the best QB ever to play the game, but I think the gap between him and Montana/Manning/Marino etc. is smaller than the conventional wisdom would suggest. To me, the longevity was the reason he's the GOAT. Any given year other than his MVP years, he wasn't necessarily the best QB out there..but even in the down years, he was still the second or third best QB statistically, and come January he was always clutch. He played at a high level until the very end of his career, and it's unlikely anyone is going to catch most of his counting stats because he was so good for so long.
But Mahomes is the only one who might.