alfadriver wrote: In reply to wbjones: I've not heard any of the talking heads talk about a fade pass. I saw most of them agree that the play was correct based on the coverage, and that it was man coverage where a rookie would have been picked by the two other players. Most of the time, a quick slant like that works. A fade would have been a good call, too- probably even with the two guys we were talking about. But that does not mean it was the worst call ever. What's funny about all of this "worst call ever" talk- it completely minimizes the fact that that a player figured out what was going on, and executed his job better than everyone else did. Had Seattle scored- it would have been a good call. Instead of pointing out that Butler really did an amazing job seeing what was going on AND made a great play, we just assume that the offense made the worst call ever. Wilson *could* have thrown the ball a little to the right, which would have made the reciever the only one who could have caught it (and would have made the contact pass interference). The other reciever *could* have pushed the defensive back into the path of Butler just a little. Then again, had Seattle converted a 3rd down in the 3rd quarter, when the reciever had the ball in his hands, in scoring position, all of this one play stuff would have probably been moot.
the "talking heads" to which I was referring were Dan Patrick, all the cast of Around the Horn, and the guys on PTI
Patrick said that even if the pass had been completed and he had scored, that he, Dan Patrick, would still have said it was the wrong pass .. would have congratulated the result, but that a fade … where ONLY the Sea Hawks receiver could have caught it would have been the better call
several QB's that were interviewed said that Wilson missed slightly on ball placement… needed to be back shoulder, needed to be lower … yada yada yada … and others agreed with the OC that the receiver should have fought for the ball harder … whatever … (that, to me, sounded like the OC was trying to shift blame .. kind of a chicken E36 M3 move)
I really don't think that it was the worst call ever, I do think that there were better options for Seattle .. though I'm quite happy with the outcome of the game