wrek496
New Reader
4/28/12 2:35 a.m.
I would blow it all on something Italian and learn a horrible lesson probably. If there was some supervision it would get better. Buy an Alfa GTV-6 in reasonable shape. Drive the piss out of it for a spell, sell it for a profit. Audi quattro turbo. Subaru RS. Buy a collectible car that's value is rising, drive it hard, sell, repeat. $40,000 would keep me in a fast car for years.
32k for a Chevy Volt and 8k for a stage rally car. (I have almost 7k into my rally car right now and it needs about a grand to be "done", so it's not a random number. I wish I had the other $32k
)
Edit: Crud, I'm not good at reading rules late at night. I guess I'll have to throw some options on the Volt to get it to 35k and limit the rally car to 5k...
It depends on the rules.
If I can buy a sub-$5000 second car, but put part of the main budget into mods, I'd do exactly what I'm already doing, only with a bigger budget.. Lightly modded Mazda2 DD, totaling about $20k, and the rest into a super nice restomod track/weekend 325IS.
If its gotta be 35k/5k, there's a lot of options. I think I'd probably go with either a Miata or MR2 for the cheap car. For the $35K, I think it'd have to be an STi hatch.
If I get to keep my current cars, I'll spend the $35k either on some form of Porsche, probably a 993, something awesome and vintage and a huge waste of money, or an S2000 CR.
Jere
Dork
4/28/12 10:07 p.m.
I would buy a turbo sentra project (or something to that extent) that someone already built for the 1.5K. Use it for parts to build my own supercar like a Midlana/Atom and part out the rest of the Sentra.
With the 30K I would go for one of these
( yeah I know they didn't actually make um but I am never going to have 35K either)
Ian F
MegaDork
4/29/12 8:08 a.m.
I'm bummed about the Aptera as well. I really wanted one of those. Hell, I was even trying to figure out how to become a dealer. Loved that car/bike/thing... data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/50cc9/50cc9f0a0b897d7157a9b219f91235091c7af929" alt=""
930T RUF.....might as well buy a 911 that is a man's 911
And considering I've driven two ruf 930t's that sold for 28-30k, I'd spend the other 10k on a SVT lightning(I know, breaking your 5k rule, whatever) data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6e320/6e320c96a29db9f753046aad2a262b6e9b4e15ad" alt=""
For explination of "Man's Porsche" Cannot rely on fancy computers to save you in the event of stupidity......930's sit in their parking spot plotting ways to kill you afterall.....data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7b3b4/7b3b4698950764abddce6a3864db5baa5bb6bd32" alt=""
tuna55
MegaDork
4/30/12 11:45 a.m.
I have $40,000.
Boy, that did feel nice. How do I make it happen?
I would get an FR-S or BRZ with as many options ticked as I want, and the best fullsize long bed pickup truck that $5k could get, assuming I have the space to park it.
Late-model Mustang 5.0 and a Toyota Corolla station wagon.
Oh, wait...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b8d53/b8d535c9e5f1c42c177b8788d6c29928a819f66f" alt=""
The answer is clearly yellow IROC!!!
http://superlitecars.com/gallery-slc/
http://superlitecars.com/superlite-coupe/
It is close to $40K and I would walk in Winter to own that
In reply to mtn:
Pay off bills so that I could get back within my means and actually be able to do car stuff again!
But to add constructively to this exercise, I'd buy my wife a fun car and get myself an '02-03 Xtype with a manual transmission and strip it for the track. Mine would be the cheap one as I've already got a fun car and she gave up her fun car when our son came along.
Luke
UberDork
5/1/12 1:09 p.m.
Lotus 7 replica of some description, and an '80s 911. ~20K each.
I don't have a "Winter" to deal with, per se data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/49bfa/49bfaed255a31cfd75077dbaf9632965fbf866e8" alt=""
edit: that's not fair, actually. I'm mixing US car pricing with Australian weather. Just the Lotus, then. And maybe a cheap Volvo wagon for a bike hauler.
Jeep Cherokee = $4k
Lotus Elise w/ aftermarket supercharger, Nitrons = $36k